Do you want content like this delivered to your inbox?
Share
Share

Two Ways to Win as a Buyer: Get the House, or Get the Deal

Geoff Goolsby

I’m a trusted real estate advisor serving Roseville and the greater Sacramento area, helping thoughtful homeowners navigate buying and selling with ...

I’m a trusted real estate advisor serving Roseville and the greater Sacramento area, helping thoughtful homeowners navigate buying and selling with ...

Nov 13

Buyer Representation • Roseville, CA

Two Ways to Win as a Buyer: Get the House, or Get the Deal

Are you beating out other offers to land the home, or getting the best possible price when there is a deal to be had? Those are two different paths, and I measured both in my own buyer results.

By Geoff Goolsby, The Goolsby Group • Published November 13, 2026 • Data: MetroList MLS export, TrendVision and offer email records

When a buyer asks whether an agent is any good, they are usually asking two different questions at once. Can you get me the house when five other people want it? And will I pay less than everyone else? Most agents blur the two together, but they are different games with different numbers.

So I pulled my own records and measured each path on its own. Path 1 is getting the house in a crowd. Path 2 is getting a great deal when there is room to negotiate. I will show you where I win big and where I only break even with the market, because that is what you need to know to choose an agent.

Path 1Getting the houseAre you beating out multiple other offers?
12multiple-offer closings (next best: 10)
68%real offers accepted (28 of 41)
Measured by: closings and offers accepted
Path 2Getting the dealAre you getting the best possible price?
1.9 ptsunder market on list price
88.9%best case vs. original price
Measured by: median close vs. list and original price

Sources: MetroList MLS export of 35 buyer closings (Geoff Goolsby); Roseville multiple-offer sales since May 2023 (2,642); Roseville sales with no multiple offers in 2025 (3,017); offer records from email since Nov 2023. Compiled November 13, 2026. See the disclaimer for definitions and limits.

Path 1: Getting the house

Can I really win when several buyers want the same house?

Yes. I have closed more multiple-offer buyer purchases in Roseville than any other agent in the MLS.

In the last three-plus years I have closed 12 multiple-offer buyer purchases in Roseville. The MLS shows 1,715 agents who represented a buyer in one of those sales. The next best agent closed 10, then two agents with 9 each.

Multiple-offer buyer purchases closed, Roseville12 closings vs. 10, 9 and 9 for the next agents, out of 1,715 buyer's agents
Geoff GoolsbyNext best agents
Geoff Goolsby
12
Next best agent
10
Third and fourth (tied)
9 and 9

Source: MetroList MLS, Roseville multiple-offer sales since May 2023 (2,642 sales). Counts are closings where the agent represented the buyer.

The honest trade-offTwelve is a count of wins, and it says nothing about how many offers it took. That is why the next section shows my full offer record, losses included.

How often does one of my offers get accepted?

28 of the 41 real offers I have written, which is 68%.

I wrote 46 offers over three years. I take out two lowball offers a client chose to make and three offers the buyer rescinded, which leaves 41. I won 28.

Offer record, last three-plus years46 offers written, 41 real, 28 accepted
68%accepted
Accepted: 28Not won: 13
Offers written
46
Real offers (minus 2 lowballs, 3 rescinded)
41
Accepted
28

Offer count is approximate because it comes from email subjects. A win means a closing in the MLS export, plus one closing I confirmed myself.

The 13 I did not win were mostly real fights. The seven I can check in the MLS drew between 2 and 15 offers each, including two homes with 9, and they closed between 100% and 113% of list. Eleven of the 13 belong to four buyers who kept searching, and one of those four bought with me in the end.

The honest trade-offI have not yet confirmed whether four of the 13 losses were multiple-offer situations, so I am not claiming every loss was a bidding war.

Do I pay more than the market to win?

About what the market pays. In a bidding war, my story is winning, not saving.

My median close was 101.3% of list price, against 100.0% for all 2,642 Roseville multiple-offer sales. In the two-offer situations that make up most of my wins, it was 100.4% against 100.0%. Look at how it moves as the crowd gets bigger:

Close price vs. list, by number of competing offersRoughly market price to win, and more in the biggest fights
My median close vs. listRoseville market median
2 competing offers • my 6 deals
100.4%
100.0%
3 competing offers • my 3 deals
97.5%
100.4%
4 competing offers • my 1 deal
101.8%
101.1%
5 or more offers • my 2 deals
107.3%
103.8%

Bars start at 95% so the gaps are visible. Source: MetroList MLS; Roseville multiple-offer sales since May 2023 (2,642). Each tier holds only 1 to 6 of my deals.

The honest trade-offThe tiers are small: one to six of my deals each. The 3-offer result is the only one under market, and I would not build a promise on three deals.

Path 2: Getting the deal

What happens when there is no bidding war?

That is where my buyers have closed meaningfully under the market.

When no bidding war is in the way, my 13 buyer purchases from 2023 to 2026 closed at a median 97.8% of list and 96.8% of the original price. The Roseville market median in 2025, across 3,017 sales with no multiple offers, was 99.7% of list and 98.5% of original.

Deals with room to negotiateAbout 1.9 points under market on list price, 1.7 on original
My buyersRoseville market
Median close vs. list price
My 13 buyer purchases
97.8%
Roseville market, 2025
99.7%
My 6 Roseville-only deals
98.9%
Median close vs. original price
My 13 buyer purchases
96.8%
Roseville market, 2025
98.5%

Bars start at 94% so the gaps are visible. Lower is better for a buyer. Close vs. list is close price divided by the final list price; close vs. original uses the first list price.

What does 1.9 points mean in dollars? On a $588,000 home, the Roseville-area median sold price in October 2026, it is about $11,000. That is what my buyers have averaged against the market on negotiable homes. It is not what you will save on every house, and I would be wary of any agent who promises that.

The honest trade-offMy 13 deals include Rocklin, El Dorado Hills, Colfax and other towns, while the market column is Roseville only, so read the gap as a direction, not a precise number. Narrowed to my 6 Roseville deals, my median is 98.9% of list, a smaller edge.

The best three deals

Standout purchasesThree homes where the seller had room to move
Closed at88.9%of original price94.5%of list price11.1 points under original
Closed at81.0%of original price94.5%of list price19.0 points under original
Closed at89.1%of original price99.1%of list price10.9 points under original

Points under original price is 100 minus the close vs. original. These are my three best results, not typical ones; the median is 96.8% of original.

The honest trade-offThese three are the highlights of 13 deals. They show what is possible when a seller needs to move, not what to expect on every home.

Does this hold up outside Roseville?

It does, and the gap is biggest where there was room to negotiate.

I have closed 15 purchases across eight other towns: Rocklin, El Dorado Hills, Sacramento, Granite Bay, Folsom, Orangevale, Rancho Murieta and Colfax. Where there was room to negotiate, my buyers outside Roseville closed about 3 points under list at the median, the biggest gap in my results.

Roseville vs. the other eight townsMy median close vs. list, by deal type
Multiple-offer deals: median close vs. list
Roseville101.3%12 deals
Other towns102.0%8 deals
No bidding war: median close vs. list
Roseville98.9%6 deals
Other towns96.8%7 deals

Lower is better for a buyer in a negotiable deal. Source: MetroList MLS export of my buyer closings.

The honest trade-offI do not have a market comparison for those towns yet, so these are my results alone. They are not a ranking against other agents.

What does it look like when a buyer does not win right away?

Sometimes it takes six offers, and the sixth one is the right one.

One buyer wrote five offers that did not close. In one, the seller countered at full price with a 30-day escrow, and the buyer chose to walk. The sixth offer closed at 94.5% of list and 88.9% of the original price, with $19,606 in concessions.

One buyer, six offersFive did not close. The sixth closed at 94.5% of list.
1
No close
2
No close
3
No close
4
No close
5
No close
6
Closed

In one of the five, the seller countered at full price with a 30-day escrow and the buyer chose to walk. Concession dollars are often blank in the MLS, so figures like this understate what buyers received.

I tell every buyer the same thing: I will not push you into a bad deal to get a win. I stay with you until the right one comes.

The honest trade-offStaying patient has a cost. Eleven of my 13 unsuccessful offers belong to four buyers who kept searching, and that takes time and some tolerance for losing.

How do my buyers compare to the Roseville market, side by side?

Negotiable homes, no bidding warMy buyers (13 deals)Roseville market (3,017 sales, 2025)
Median close vs. list97.8%99.7%
Median close vs. original price96.8%98.5%
Sales with concessions5 of 13 flagged41% flagged

Sources: MetroList MLS export of my buyer closings (2023 to 2026); Roseville sales with no multiple offers, 2025. My 13 include Rocklin, El Dorado Hills, Colfax and other towns; the market column is Roseville only. Concession dollars are often blank in the MLS, so concession counts understate what buyers received. Lower prices are better for a buyer.

Potential UpsideYou get the houseIn crowded situations my record is 12 closings, more than any other agent in the MLS, and 28 of 41 real offers accepted.
Potential UpsideReal money on negotiable homesA median 1.9 points under the Roseville market on list price, about $11,000 on a $588,000 home. It is an average, not a promise.
Potential ConcernYou will pay market to winIn a bidding war my median close was 101.3% of list vs. 100.0% for the market. Winning is the value there, not a discount.
Potential ConcernThe market is changingMonths of inventory rose from 1.5 in spring 2024 to 3.3 in October 2026, and the average sale now closes about 96% of the original price. Everyone's numbers look better in a looser market.

My own thoughts on the matter

Personal share: I do not think a good buyer's agent is the one who wins every offer. I think it is the one who knows which fight is worth having. Some of my buyers lost out on five homes before the right one came through, and I would rather lose five than push someone into a house they will regret.

That is also why I publish the market-price truth in bidding wars. If you hire me to win a house in a crowd, you are paying for the win. If you hire me for a home with room to negotiate, you are paying for the price.

The Bigger Picture

In a bidding war, I win at about market price. When there is room to negotiate, my buyers have closed about 2 points under it.

Those are two different skills, and a lot of agents lean on whichever one sounds better. Ask any agent you interview for both numbers: how many offers they wrote, how many were accepted, and where their buyers closed against list and against the original price.

What to do if you are buying in Roseville right now

Get your approval and your number before you tour.

In a multiple-offer situation, there is no time to figure out what you can spend while the clock is running. Know your ceiling before you fall in love with a house.

Decide in advance which kind of home you are chasing.

A fresh listing with a pile of showings is a speed game. A home that has been sitting, or has dropped from its original price, is a negotiation. The strategy for each is different.

Look at the original price, not just the list price.

A home that dropped from its first asking price tells you what the seller has already moved on. In my best three deals the buyers closed 10.9 to 19.0 points under the original price.

Ask for the agent's real numbers.

Offers written, offers accepted, close vs. list and close vs. original. If you hear "I will save you thousands," ask for the data behind it. And remember that averages describe the past; they do not promise your next deal.

The bottom line

If you are buying against a crowd in Roseville, my record says I can get you the house: 12 closings, more than any other agent in the MLS, and 68% of my real offers accepted.

If you are buying a home with room to move, my buyers have averaged about 2 points under the market on list price. On the right home, that has been 5.5% under list and 11.1% under the original price.

The market has loosened this fall, with months of inventory more than doubling since spring 2024. My read is that buyers get more room to negotiate as that continues, but it will vary by neighborhood and price point. The agent who helps you tell which kind of house you are looking at is worth more than the one who promises the biggest number.

Common questions

How do you define a multiple-offer purchase?

It is a closed buyer-side sale where the home had more than one competing offer. I compared my 12 Roseville closings with all 2,642 Roseville multiple-offer sales since May 2023 in the MLS.

How do you count a win?

A win is a closing in the MLS export, plus one closing I confirmed myself. I wrote 46 offers, removed two lowball offers a client chose to make and three the buyer rescinded, and won 28 of the remaining 41.

Why do your multiple-offer closings cost about market price?

Because that is what it takes to win. My median was 101.3% of list vs. 100.0% for the market. In two-offer situations, which are most of my wins, it was 100.4% vs. 100.0%.

Does this mean I will save about $11,000?

No. About $11,000 is the 1.9-point median gap on a $588,000 home across 13 negotiable deals. It is an average of past results, and each home and seller is different.

Are these numbers only for Roseville?

The market comparisons are Roseville only. I also closed 15 purchases in eight other towns, and those show the same pattern, but I do not have a market benchmark for them yet.

What changed in the market this fall?

Months of inventory went from 1.5 in spring 2024 to 3.3 in October 2026, and the average sale now closes about 96% of the original price. That helps every buyer, not just mine.

Wanting to buy a home?

Tell me what you want, and I will show you what your competition looks like and what a realistic strategy is.

Book a Virtual Strategy SessionMeet In Person

— Geoff Goolsby · The Goolsby Group · Roseville, CA

Data and definitions: results are from a MetroList MLS export of 35 buyer closings by Geoff Goolsby; Roseville multiple-offer sales since May 2023 (2,642 sales; 1,715 buyer's agents); Roseville sales with no multiple offers in 2025 (3,017 sales); TrendVision market trends, October 2023 to October 2026; and email records of offers submitted since November 2023. Data compiled November 13, 2026. Close vs. list is close price divided by the final list price; close vs. original uses the first list price. Excluded: deals where I was on both sides, and one offer removed at my request. Offer counts are approximate because they come from email subjects. A win means a closing in the MLS export, plus one closing I confirmed myself. Concession dollars are often blank in the MLS and understate what buyers received. Samples are small: the offer-count tiers hold 1 to 6 of my deals each, and my 13 negotiable deals span several cities, so compare them with the Roseville market as a direction, not an exact measure. I have not yet confirmed whether four of my unsuccessful offers were multiple-offer situations. The $588,000 figure is the Roseville-area median sold price for October 2026. Past results do not guarantee future results, and individual outcomes vary. This is not legal or financial advice; confirm contract and financing questions with your agent, attorney or lender. Geoff Goolsby, DRE #01926125.